7 Best Black & White Cookies In The U.S.

A black and white cookie, also known as a half-and-half cookie or a “Harlequin” cookie, is a classic dessert popular in the United States. It is characterized by its distinctive appearance, with one half of the cookie coated in chocolate icing (usually dark chocolate), and the other half coated in vanilla icing (usually white or light-colored).

Key features of a black and white cookie include:

1. Shape: The cookie is typically round and flat, often resembling a disc or a small cake.
2. Texture: Black and white cookies are known for their soft and cake-like texture. They are not overly sweet and have a slight crunch on the outside.
3. Icing: The cookie is divided into two halves, and each half is frosted with a different icing. The chocolate and vanilla icings are often made with confectioners’ sugar, water or milk, and flavorings.
4. Flavor: The flavor of the cookie itself is usually a mild vanilla taste, and the contrast between the chocolate and vanilla icings provides a balanced and satisfying flavor profile.

Determining the “best” black and white cookies can be subjective, as personal preferences for taste and texture vary. However, there are several places known for producing delicious black and white cookies. Here are a few renowned establishments:

1. William Greenberg Desserts (New York City, USA): Located in Manhattan, William Greenberg Desserts is known for its classic black and white cookies. The bakery has been a fixture in New York since 1946.
2. Russ & Daughters (New York City, USA): A famous appetizing store in New York City, Russ & Daughters is known for its bagels, smoked fish, and other delicacies. Their black and white cookies are often praised for their flavor and texture.
3. Zabar’s (New York City, USA): Another iconic New York establishment, Zabar’s is a gourmet market that offers a variety of food items. Their black and white cookies are well-regarded by locals and visitors alike.
4. Amy’s Bread (New York City, USA): Amy’s Bread is a popular bakery in New York City, known for its artisanal bread and delicious pastries. Their black and white cookies are a favorite among customers.
5. Breads Bakery (New York City, USA): Breads Bakery, also located in New York City, is known for its high-quality baked goods. Their black and white cookie is often praised for its large size and classic taste.
6. Orwashers Bakery (New York City, USA): Orwashers, a historic bakery in New York City, has been serving artisanal bread and pastries since 1916. Their black and white cookies are a popular choice.
7. Levain Bakery (New York City, USA): While Levain Bakery is most famous for its giant chocolate chip cookies, they also offer a delicious black and white cookie that has gained popularity.
8. Larder’s Delicatessen & Bakert (Cleveland, USA): These soft, vanilla-scented cookies—a Jewish deli and bakery staple—are delicious, and less fussy to frost than you might think. Larder’s version is supersized and delicious (trust us, get two).

When searching for the best black and white cookies, it’s worth exploring local bakeries, specialty shops, or renowned bakeries in cities known for their baked goods. Keep in mind that the availability of specific items may change, so it’s a good idea to check with the establishments directly or through their websites for the latest offerings. —Vita Daily